California's Redistricting Reform Efforts Face Setbacks Despite Independent Commission Success


Governor Newsom's Vetoes Limit Local Redistricting Independence as Critics Question True Democratic Control

Sacramento, CA - While California has been nationally praised for its independent Citizens Redistricting Commission that draws state and congressional districts, recent political developments have raised questions about the state's commitment to expanding democratic redistricting reforms and the true independence of the process from political influence.

The Commission System Under Scrutiny

California's Citizens Redistricting Commission, created through voter initiatives in 2008 and 2010, was designed to take redistricting power away from the legislature and transfer it to citizens. The 14-member commission consists of five Democrats, five Republicans, and four members from neither major party.

However, investigative reporting has revealed that the commission's independence may not be as robust as initially intended. A ProPublica investigation found that Democratic party operatives successfully influenced the commission through organized groups that presented themselves as ordinary Californians but were actually coordinated by party officials. One woman who claimed to represent the Asian community of the San Gabriel Valley was actually a lobbyist who grew up in rural Idaho and lives in Sacramento.

The investigation concluded that Democratic incumbents became "once again insulated from the will of the electorate" despite the commission's stated goal of directly linking lawmakers' political fate to their constituents.

Governor's Role in Limiting Local Reform

Governor Gavin Newsom has drawn criticism from reform advocates for repeatedly blocking efforts to expand independent redistricting to local governments. In October 2023, Newsom vetoed Assembly Bill 1248, which would have required cities and counties with more than 300,000 residents to establish independent redistricting commissions before the 2030 cycle.

This marked the second time in four years that Newsom vetoed legislation requiring independent redistricting commissions for some local governments. In his veto message, Newsom cited budget concerns, saying the bill would create a "state-reimbursable mandate in the tens of millions".

"We're deeply confused and frustrated, why the governor would choose to veto a proven democracy reform," said Jonathan Mehta Stein, executive director for California Common Cause.

Impact on Party Balance and Representation

The redistricting commission's work has had significant effects on California's political landscape. Independent studies by the Public Policy Institute of California, the National Journal, and Ballotpedia have shown that California now has some of the most competitive districts in the nation. In the previous 10 years under legislative redistricting, incumbents were so safe that only one Congressional seat changed party control in 255 elections.

Analysis shows the Citizens Redistricting Commission largely satisfied expectations that it would produce plans that are fair to each major party and increase electoral competitiveness. However, the final map resulted in 36 Democratic leaning districts, 11 competitive districts, and 5 Republican districts.

Reform Organization Perspectives

Reform California, a statewide political reform organization, has been advocating for greater transparency and accountability in the redistricting process. The organization has called for stronger oversight mechanisms to prevent the kind of behind-the-scenes influence documented by investigative reports.

Current Challenges and Future Outlook

Recent political developments have raised new concerns about potential interference with the commission's independence. Democratic leaders, including those in Newsom's orbit, have reportedly signaled willingness to have the commission redraw maps in response to potential redistricting moves by Texas Republicans.

While California uses an independent commission to draw maps, "in theory, Newsom could ask the commission to draw new maps," according to recent reporting.

The League of Women Voters of California continues to advocate for expanded independent redistricting, noting that "local gerrymandering persists" despite the state's success at the state level. The organization called Newsom's veto of AB 1248 "a missed opportunity to eradicate local gerrymandering".

Legislative Progress Despite Setbacks

Despite the major veto, some progress has been made. Newsom did sign AB 764, which addresses ambiguities in current redistricting laws by explicitly banning consideration of incumbency and increasing standards for public engagement. He also signed bills creating citizens redistricting commissions for Sacramento County and Orange County.

Reform advocates continue pushing for comprehensive redistricting reform as "a long-term solution for building truly representative elections and a democracy that includes everyone".

As California approaches the next redistricting cycle following the 2030 census, the tension between political expedience and democratic reform continues to shape debates over who truly controls the redrawing of political boundaries in the nation's most populous state.

Sources

  1. California Citizens Redistricting Commission. (2025). Welcome to the 2020 California Citizens Redistricting Commission. https://wedrawthelines.ca.gov/
  2. The American Redistricting Project. (2024). California. https://thearp.org/state/california/
  3. League of Women Voters of California. (2023, December 8). Redistricting California. https://lwvc.org/issue/redistricting-california/
  4. California Secretary of State. California Redistricting. https://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/california-redistricting
  5. Wikipedia. (2025). California Citizens Redistricting Commission. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Citizens_Redistricting_Commission
  6. All About Redistricting. (2024, September 16). California. https://redistricting.lls.edu/state/california/
  7. Common Cause California. (2024, July 29). Citizens Redistricting Commission. https://www.commoncause.org/california/work/citizens-redistricting-commission/
  8. Common Cause California. (2023, April 27). Anti-Gerrymandering Redistricting Reform Gaining Momentum in the Legislature. https://www.commoncause.org/california/press/anti-gerrymandering-redistricting-reform-gaining-momentum-in-the-legislature/
  9. Public Policy Institute of California. (2024, September 24). Assessing California's Redistricting Commission: Effects on Partisan Fairness and Competitiveness. https://www.ppic.org/publication/assessing-californias-redistricting-commission-effects-on-partisan-fairness-and-competitiveness/
  10. ProPublica. (2020, February 16). How Democrats Fooled California's Redistricting Commission. https://www.propublica.org/article/how-democrats-fooled-californias-redistricting-commission
  11. CalMatters. (2023, October 11). Independent redistricting stalls in California. https://calmatters.org/politics/2023/10/redistricting-california-newsom/
  12. Texas Tribune. (2025, July 3). House Democrats, California leaders weigh tit-for-tat redistricting if Texas Republicans redraw maps. https://www.texastribune.org/2025/07/03/redistricting-texas-california-democrats-retaliation-trump-newsom/
  13. AP News. (2023, October 9). California governor vetoes bill requiring independent panels to draw local voting districts. https://apnews.com/article/redistricting-california-gerrymandering-independent-commission-553a08590ac29e0dd8115073663e8f2a
  14. Ballotpedia. Redistricting in California. https://ballotpedia.org/Redistricting_in_California
  15. The Fulcrum. (2021, October 6). California governor signs redistricting, voting rights and campaign finance bills. https://thefulcrum.us/electoral-reforms/california-reform-bills

California Redistricting News Story | Claude | Claude

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How much money family of 4 needs to live comfortably in U.S. cities

Image
How much money family of 4 needs to live comfortably in U.S. cities The income a family of 4 needs to live comfortably in 20 major U.S. cities Mike Winters cnbc.com A family of four needs to make more than $275,000 to live comfortably in some of the most expensive U.S. cities, a recent SmartAsset analysis reveals . “Comfortable” is defined as the income needed to cover a 50/30/20 budget for a family of two adults and two kids. This budget assumes that 50% of the monthly income can pay for necessities like housing and utility costs, 30% can cover discretionary spending and 20% can be set aside for savings or investments. SmartAsset extrapolated the income needed for a 50/30/20 budget based on the cost of necessities, using data from the MIT Living Wage Calculator. Here’s a look how much income a family of four needs to live comfortably in the 20 most expensive U.S. cities:...
Read more

California is burning under Gavin’s leadership (Opinion) | TahoeDailyTribune.com

California is burning under Gavin’s leadership (Opinion) | TahoeDailyTribune.com tahoedailytribune.com California is burning under Gavin’s leadership (Opinion) Republican State Senators Brian Dahle and minority leader Brian W. Jones As Governor Newsom prepared to take the national stage on Thursday, California Senate Republicans take offense that he continues to paint a rosy picture of the Golden State. Under his leadership, California is failing as a result of legislative Democrats’ misguided policies and families are feeling the pinch of those bad policies with the high costs of living, public safety concerns, and rampant homelessness.  “Gavin Newsom has no credibility to go on national stage to tout his successes for California,” said Senate Minority Leader Brian W. Jones ( R-San Diego ). “The Golden State is burning with one crisis after a...
Read more

Sacramento Report: Lawmakers Want to Cut Red Tape to Ramp up Battery Storage   | Voice of San Diego

Image
PALM DESERT, CA – The Assembly Select Committee on Permitting Reform, chaired by Assemblymember Buffy Wicks (D-Oakland), convened a hearing and tour today to address the barriers posed by California’s outdated permitting processes to clean energy infrastructure development. California Lawmakers Push to Overhaul "Slow and Outdated" Permitting Process California legislature's ambitious climate and housing goals are stuck in a regulatory morass of their own making in the state's complex and time-consuming permitting process. Led by Assemblymember Buffy Wicks (D-Oakland), the Assembly Select Committee on Permitting Reform is conducting a comprehensive review of the state's regulatory framework, aiming to streamline approvals for critical infrastructure projects while maintaining environmental protections. The urgency for reform comes as California faces multiple interconnected crises. The state aims to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2045 and desper...
Read more